My trans temp guage didn't seem to work either.  When Aladdin shows my trans temp to be around 180 (normal flat level temp) the analog guage is pegged at cold.  I was concerned about it also, until this summer when, after a long uphill, the Aladdin showed more than 200, the analog guage started to climb a little.  I think you'll find that Beaver just didn't use a very accurate sender. 
I love my Beaver, but the engineers clearly lost focus during their engineering from time to time.