Les
If you're referring to the rad cap on the expansion tank and if it is similar to mine (2006 Monterey w/Cat C9), remember that the first clockwise rotation stop when installing the cap only takes it partway and up to the point where you need to push down on it firmly to get it to rotate an additional 20-30 degrees in the same direction where it will finally lock into its sealed and retained position. I can only assume that if your caps were installed without assuring that they had been rotated into their final position, perhaps they were able to vibrate off.
When removing the cap and assuming it has been installed correctly, you need to push down firmly on the cap before you begin the counterclockwise rotation...otherwise it will not rotate at all.
Just a thought.
Jim