Thanks for the explanation, Gerald.
The old "Ford" solenoids were definitely not made for constant duty, and there could be a difference in product quality that dictated how well they'd hold up. I soon learned, as a young guy on the farm and then with our Pace Arrow, to not waste time and money on cheap solenoids, and ditto for isolators. One tough boost solenoid on the PArrow lasted dozens of miles one night, as I had to hold the Boost switch down after a failed alternator compromised headlamp power. I had used it to replace a less than stellar factory solenoid.
I note they use "Ford" type solenoids before both the house and chassis 12v panels in our Beavers. Those style switches have sure been around awhile, and when well made they still do the job. An impressively long record for a single automotive idea.
The Big Boy's interior construction seems well suited to its task, and I would expect little trouble with it; the BIRD unit would be to me more suspicious during a system failure. Since it's wires are subject to movement and pinching as the access door it's attached to is used (on mine at least), it's connections would be a first place to look.
Joel