Jim,
If you have power and a good ground to your compressor and it does not run, it is bad. 
A Viair 380C will have about twice the volume of your current compressor at 1.34 CFM, and a 480C has even more at 1.76 CFM. Also you could use a 400C with a 2.54 CFM, but the duty cycle will drop from 100% at 100PSI down to 33%, so a leak in the system may burn up the compressor. Therefore, I prefer to stick with a 100% duty cycle compressor.
You can look over the options, and decide which compressor is best for you at;  http://www.viaircorp.com
I found the best deals on Viair compressors on EBay, but there are OK deals on Amazon,
Gerald