Are the lug nuts one-piece with a tapered face, or two piece (have a sort of rotating washer) with a flat face? As you probably know the hub pilot style use the flat face lug nut. I would bet they are hub pilot. The stud pilot went out of favor in the 80s.
A lot of the aluminum wheels will work with either style (they are made with the tapered hole and machined for hub piloting).
You may need to go to longer wheel studs too, since the aluminum wheels are thicker.